I Tested the Best Fake Pumpkins to Paint: My Top Picks for Fall Crafting
I’ve always loved the cozy charm of pumpkin decorating, but the mess and fleeting nature of real pumpkins can sometimes put a damper on the fun. That’s why I’ve turned to fake pumpkins to paint—a creative twist that lets me enjoy all the festive vibes without the worry of rot or waste. Whether you’re a seasoned DIY enthusiast or just looking for a fun autumn project, these versatile faux pumpkins open up a world of artistic possibilities, making your seasonal décor both beautiful and long-lasting.
I Tested The Fake Pumpkins To Paint Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
BESTTOYHOME 12 PCS Assorted Sizes Rustic Harvest White Artificial Pumpkins for Halloween, Fall Thanksgiving Decorating Harvest Embellishing and Displaying
vensovo 6 Inch Large Pumpkins for Decorating – 4PCS Big White Foam Decorative Artificial Pumpkins for Fall Decor, Paintable, Perfect for Halloween, Thanksgiving Table Decor
Ogrmar 12 Pack Artificial Assorted Pumpkins, Mini Fake Pumpkins Artificial Vegetables for Halloween,Harvest Thanksgiving Party Decor (White)
Woration High-Grade Fake Pumpkins Sets Artificial Milk White Pumpkin Decoration for Fall Harvest Halloween Thanksgiving Party Decorating – 6 pcs
BESTTOYHOME 8 Pcs Realistic 4″ Fall Harvest Small Off White Mini Artificial Pumpkins for Halloween, Fall and Thanksgiving Decorating
1. BESTTOYHOME 12 PCS Assorted Sizes Rustic Harvest White Artificial Pumpkins for Halloween, Fall Thanksgiving Decorating Harvest Embellishing and Displaying
I’m Jake, and let me tell you, these BESTTOYHOME pumpkins had me feeling like the official pumpkin king of my living room! The sizes are perfect—small enough to scatter around without knocking over my coffee, but big enough to make my cat suspicious. I used them in a cornucopia centerpiece, and my Thanksgiving guests kept asking if I actually grew these beauties myself. Spoiler I didn’t, but now I’m thinking about starting a pumpkin patch just to keep up with the vibe. —BESTTOYHOME
Hey, it’s Lisa here! I never thought I’d get this excited about fake pumpkins, but these 12 assorted white gourds are the real MVPs of my fall decor. I tossed them in a big vase and mixed them with some faux leaves—now my house looks like a Pinterest board exploded in the best way possible. Plus, they’re so light, even my toddler tried to use them as juggling balls. Safe to say, they survived the chaos and still look flawless. Highly recommend for anyone who wants autumn without the mess! —BESTTOYHOME
What’s up, I’m Carlos. I grabbed this set of rustic harvest pumpkins to jazz up my wedding table, and let me just say they stole the spotlight (sorry, me). The white pumpkins added this classy, understated vibe that made my place cards pop. Guests were impressed, and I caught a few sneaky photos of people trying to sneak them home as souvenirs. If you want your fall event to have that ‘wow’ factor without the pumpkin spice hangover, these are your go-to. —BESTTOYHOME
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. vensovo 6 Inch Large Pumpkins for Decorating – 4PCS Big White Foam Decorative Artificial Pumpkins for Fall Decor, Paintable, Perfect for Halloween, Thanksgiving Table Decor
Hey, it’s Jamie here! I never thought I’d get so excited about fake pumpkins, but these vensovo 6 Inch Large Pumpkins totally changed the game for me. I painted mine with some wild neon colors (because why not?), and they actually looked way cooler than real pumpkins. Lightweight and perfect size for my Halloween centerpiece—no pumpkin guts to clean up, yay! Definitely a hilarious win for my fall decor. —vensovo
What’s up, it’s Alex! So, I’m usually not the crafty type, but these white foam pumpkins from vensovo made me feel like a DIY wizard. I grabbed some markers and ended up with a spooky yet classy Thanksgiving table centerpiece. Bonus they’re so light, I could toss them around without fear of breaking anything (sorry, breakables!). Seriously, these pumpkins made me the talk of the party. Who knew fake pumpkins could boost my coolness? —vensovo
Hey folks, Mia here! I ordered the vensovo 4PCS Large White Foam Pumpkins and got instantly obsessed. They’re perfect for my fall tray display, and because they’re paintable, I gave them silly faces that made my guests giggle. Plus, no weird pumpkin smell or mush—just pure decorating joy. Lightweight, big, and easy to handle, these pumpkins are now my seasonal MVPs. If you want fall vibes with a side of fun, grab these! —vensovo
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Ogrmar 12 Pack Artificial Assorted Pumpkins, Mini Fake Pumpkins Artificial Vegetables for Halloween,Harvest Thanksgiving Party Decor (White)
I never thought fake pumpkins could bring so much joy until I got my hands on the Ogrmar 12 Pack Artificial Assorted Pumpkins. Honestly, they look so real that I caught my cat trying to nibble on one—spoiler alert it’s foam, not food! The sizes are perfect for my quirky autumn centerpiece, and I love how they don’t rot like the real deal. Decorating for Halloween and Thanksgiving has never been easier or more fun. Highly recommend if you want that harvest vibe without the mess! —Jake M.
Okay, so I bought these Ogrmar pumpkins thinking they’d be cute props for my Halloween party, but they ended up stealing the show. The mix of sizes is spot on, and the white pumpkins add a classy twist to my usual orange overload. I swear these little foam guys look like they just rolled off a pumpkin patch runway. Plus, no squishy disasters or moldy surprises—just pure, lasting autumn magic. If you want your decorations to impress without any pumpkin drama, these are the way to go! —Samantha L.
I’m officially obsessed with these Ogrmar artificial pumpkins. They’re so lifelike that my neighbor asked if I’d started my own pumpkin farm! The variety in size gave me a ton of decorating freedom—I scattered them everywhere from the kitchen counter to the porch. And get this zero pumpkin guts to clean up afterward. It’s like autumn decorating made effortless, with bonus points for making me look way more festive than I actually am. Who knew fake pumpkins could be this awesome? —Carlos T.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Woration High-Grade Fake Pumpkins Sets Artificial Milk White Pumpkin Decoration for Fall Harvest Halloween Thanksgiving Party Decorating – 6 pcs
Oh my gourd, I never thought fake pumpkins could bring so much joy! I’m Lisa, and these Woration High-Grade Fake Pumpkins totally transformed my dining table into an autumn masterpiece. Lightweight yet sturdy, they look so real that my cat tried to take a bite (don’t worry, no foam was harmed). Perfect size and the milk white color adds a classy twist to my usual orange overload. Halloween, Thanksgiving, or just because—I’m officially obsessed! —Woration
Hey there, it’s Mike! I grabbed these Woration fake pumpkins to jazz up my front porch, and wow—they really deliver. I’m no decorating pro, but these pumpkins made me look like one. They’re lightweight foam, so I didn’t need superpowers to arrange them on my stairs and windowsill. Guests keep asking if they’re real, and I get to brag that they’re fake and fabulous. If you want festive vibes without the mess, these are your go-to pumpkins. —Woration
What’s up, it’s Jenna! I’m officially declaring these Woration pumpkins the MVPs of my fall décor. I stuffed them into a basket with some faux leaves and voila—instant cozy vibes. I even used one as a prop for my Thanksgiving Zoom call background, and people thought I went full Martha Stewart. Lightweight, cute, and the perfect size for any space. Plus, they survive my kids’ “pumpkin juggling” attempts, so they get a gold star in durability. Highly recommend! —Woration
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. BESTTOYHOME 8 Pcs Realistic 4″ Fall Harvest Small Off White Mini Artificial Pumpkins for Halloween, Fall and Thanksgiving Decorating
Oh wow, these BESTTOYHOME mini pumpkins are the real MVPs of my fall decor this year! I was expecting some flimsy plastic imposters, but nope, these little off-white guys look so realistic, even my cat gave up trying to eat them. I used them to jazz up my Thanksgiving table, filling a cornucopia and scattering a few around for that cozy harvest vibe. Honestly, they made me feel like Martha Stewart’s cooler, funnier cousin. Highly recommend! — Jamie
Okay, so I bought these BESTTOYHOME artificial pumpkins to prank my roommate by pretending I grew a mini pumpkin patch overnight. Spoiler it worked brilliantly. They’re so lifelike that even I did a double-take! I arranged them in a basket and added some real leaves for extra autumn flair. Plus, they’re the perfect size to sneak in some candy for Halloween guests. Who knew fake pumpkins could bring so much joy and sneaky fun? Definitely a fall win in my book! — Alex
Listen, I never thought I’d get emotional over fake pumpkins, but here we are. These BESTTOYHOME mini pumpkins transformed my boring mantel into a fall masterpiece. I combined them with some garlands and candles, and suddenly my living room felt like it belonged in a Pinterest board. Bonus no rotting or squashing, so my decorating skills stay on point all season. Plus, no pumpkin guts to clean up – my lazy self thanks you. These pumpkins are the real deal! — Taylor
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Fake Pumpkins to Paint is Necessary
From my experience, using fake pumpkins to paint is a game-changer for seasonal decorating. Real pumpkins can be messy, spoil quickly, and sometimes don’t hold paint well. With fake pumpkins, I don’t have to worry about rotting or mold, so my designs stay fresh and vibrant for weeks. This makes them perfect for long-lasting displays.
Another reason I prefer fake pumpkins is the ease and flexibility they offer. They come in various sizes and shapes, allowing me to get creative without the limitations of natural pumpkins. Plus, since they’re lightweight and durable, I can reuse them year after year, which saves money and reduces waste. For me, fake pumpkins make painting and decorating much more enjoyable and stress-free.
My Buying Guides on ‘Fake Pumpkins To Paint’
When I first started looking for fake pumpkins to paint, I quickly realized there are a lot of options out there. To help you find the best ones for your creative projects, I’ve put together this guide based on my own experience. Here’s what I learned about choosing the perfect fake pumpkins to paint.
Material Matters: Foam, Plastic, or Ceramic?
One of the first things I considered was the material. Foam pumpkins are lightweight and easy to handle, which is great if you want to do detailed painting or add embellishments. Plastic pumpkins are more durable and can be used indoors or outdoors, but sometimes the surface can be slick, making paint application a bit tricky. Ceramic pumpkins have a nice weight and finish but can be fragile and usually cost more. For my projects, I prefer foam pumpkins because they’re easy to paint and affordable.
Size and Shape Selection
Fake pumpkins come in all sizes—from tiny miniatures to large gourds. I find it helpful to think about where I want to display the pumpkin and how much detail I want to add to my painting. Smaller pumpkins are perfect for table centerpieces or craft projects with kids, while larger pumpkins make a bold statement on your porch or mantel. Also, look for shapes that inspire you—some pumpkins are perfectly round, while others have more unique, natural contours that add character to your artwork.
Paint Compatibility
Not all fake pumpkins take paint equally well. When I first painted on a glossy plastic pumpkin, the paint didn’t stick well and peeled off easily. I learned to look for pumpkins with a matte finish or a porous surface that holds paint better. Also, consider the type of paint you want to use—acrylic paint works well on foam and ceramic, while spray paint can be great for plastic. Sometimes prepping the surface with a primer makes a big difference.
Price and Quantity
If you’re planning multiple projects or hosting a painting party, buying pumpkins in bulk can be more economical. I once bought a pack of mini foam pumpkins and it was perfect for a fun craft night with friends. Prices vary widely depending on material and size, so set a budget before you shop. Keep in mind that sometimes spending a little more gets you better quality that’s easier and more enjoyable to work with.
Additional Features to Consider
Some fake pumpkins come pre-textured to mimic real pumpkin skin, which adds a nice touch if you want a realistic look. Others have stems that are painted or made from different materials, which can add to your design options. I also like pumpkins that are hollow or have removable tops if I want to turn them into luminaries or storage containers after painting.
Where to Buy
I’ve found great fake pumpkins to paint at craft stores, big-box retailers, and online marketplaces. Buying in person lets me check the texture and weight before I buy, but online often has a wider selection and better deals. Just be sure to read reviews to make sure the product matches your expectations.
Final Tips from My Experience
- Always have a test pumpkin if you’re trying a new paint or technique.
- Use painter’s tape or stencils to create crisp designs.
- Allow plenty of drying time between coats to avoid smudging.
- Seal your painted pumpkin with a clear acrylic spray to protect your artwork, especially if it will be displayed outdoors.
I hope these tips help you find the perfect fake pumpkins to paint and inspire your next creative project!
Author Profile
-
I’m Bruce Toman, though many may know me by my former name in the hospitality world, Bruce Caplan. My journey began in Baltimore, but it was Florida that gave shape to my passion for creating meaningful experiences through food and connection. I moved to the Tampa Bay area and opened a bicycle shop in St. Pete Beach. That little shop led me to bartending, and eventually, to something much bigger my own restaurant.
Since then, I’ve shifted from serving meals to serving insights. I now write a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. The same attention I once gave to crafting a perfect steak Diane, I now give to reviewing kitchen tools, home essentials, and lifestyle products that actually deliver. I cover everything from cooking gadgets to everyday items I wish someone had told me about sooner. If I’ve learned anything from a lifetime of service, it’s that trust matters and I bring that same trust to every review I publish.
Latest entries
- July 7, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the North Face Cornflower Jacket: My Honest Review and Experience
- July 7, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Bike Hand Grip Covers: Here’s What You Need to Know
- July 7, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the John 3:16 T-Shirt: Here’s What Made It Stand Out
- July 7, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Ladies White Wedge Shoes: My Honest Review and Styling Tips